Written by

Gina Conley, MS

June 1, 2026

How Our Views on Birth Have Changed Over the Years as Birth Workers

Birth Options, Motherhood, Podcast

When we first entered the world of birth work, we thought we had it figured out.

Like many birth professionals, our early perspectives were shaped by our personal experiences, education, mentors, and the environments we worked in. Over time, though, our understanding of birth evolved in ways we never expected. Supporting hundreds of families through pregnancy, labor, birth, and postpartum has humbled us, challenged us, and ultimately helped us become better providers.

Today, we want to share how our views have changed over the years—and why we believe the most empowering births don’t fit into one specific mold.

Subscribe to our YouTube Channel for more weekly workouts and educational videos! We publish one new workout video and 2-3 educational videos a week on our channel.

The Polarization Within the Birth World

If you spend any time in birth spaces online, you’ll quickly notice that birth has become deeply polarized.

On one side, there’s the “natural birth only” perspective:

Birth should always be physiologic
Interventions are harmful
Hospitals are dangerous
Everyone should avoid epidurals, inductions, and C-sections whenever possible

On the other side, there’s the highly medicalized perspective:

Modern medicine is always best
Interventions are no big deal
Patients should simply trust providers
Questioning recommendations is viewed as unsafe or uninformed

Unfortunately, both sides can become dismissive, judgmental, and even hostile toward each other.

And when that happens, the person who suffers most is the birthing individual caught in the middle.

Over the years, we’ve realized that birth does not need to be a battle between holistic care and medical care. There is room for collaboration. There is room for nuance. There is room for individualized care.

Most importantly, there is room for people to make decisions that feel right for them.

Gina’s Early Birth Experience Changed Everything

Before Gina became pregnant, birth was honestly something she didn’t think much about.

Like many people, she assumed:

Birth would be painful
Epidurals were standard
Doctors knew best
You just “got through it”

There was very little emotional attachment to the experience itself.

But during pregnancy, things shifted.

After taking childbirth education classes and learning more about physiologic birth, she became increasingly interested in the idea of an unmedicated birth. At the same time, though, she also became increasingly fearful and distrustful of the medical system.

The messaging she absorbed often framed providers as:

Pushy
Dismissive
Intervention-focused
Untrustworthy

Unfortunately, her actual birth experience reinforced many of those fears.

She felt unheard.
She felt dismissed.
She felt rushed.
She felt unsupported.

Even though the outcome was physically healthy, emotionally the experience left a lasting impact.

That birth became the catalyst for entering birth work—but it also heavily shaped her early beliefs about birth.

When Distrust Shapes Birth Work

In the beginning, Gina’s perspective became very centered around avoiding medical intervention.

Like many newer doulas and birth workers, there was a belief that:

Unmedicated birth was the “best” birth
Out-of-hospital birth was the most empowering
Interventions often ruined birth experiences
Providers were something clients needed protection from

This mindset wasn’t necessarily malicious. It came from personal pain, fear, and the desire to help others avoid similar trauma.

But over time, supporting more births revealed something important:

People can have empowering births in many different ways.

Some people loved their epidurals.
Some people felt empowered by planned inductions.
Some people had deeply healing C-sections.
Some people had difficult home births.
Some people loved hospital births.
Some people hated unmedicated labor.

The longer we worked in birth, the more obvious it became that there is no universal “right” way to give birth.

Roxanne’s Perspective from the Medical Side

Roxanne entered birth work from the opposite direction.

As a labor nurse, interventions initially felt routine:

Pitocin
Epidurals
Cervical exams
Inductions
C-sections

These were simply tools used every day in labor and delivery.

But Gina’s birth forced a major shift in perspective.

For the first time, Roxanne truly saw how dismissive language, lack of informed consent, and poor communication could dramatically affect someone’s birth experience.

Even when providers believe they are helping, the emotional experience matters.

A medically “normal” birth can still feel traumatic if someone:

Feels ignored
Feels coerced
Feels unsafe
Feels powerless

That realization changed everything.

Over time, Roxanne became more focused on:

Informed consent
Collaborative care
Physiologic birth support
Patient autonomy
Emotional safety during labor

She also learned that interventions themselves are not inherently good or bad.

They are simply tools.

The real question is:

Does the birthing person understand their options?
Do they feel informed?
Do they feel supported?
Are they making choices freely?

The Most Important Factor: Trust

One of the biggest lessons we’ve learned over the years is this:

The most important part of a positive birth experience is often trust.

Not necessarily:

Home birth vs hospital birth
Epidural vs unmedicated
Midwife vs OB

But trust.

Trust in:

Your provider
Your support team
Your environment
Your ability to make decisions

When people trust their team, birth often feels more collaborative and empowering—even when plans change.

When trust is absent, even an uncomplicated birth can feel frightening and traumatic.

That’s why we now encourage clients to spend more time evaluating how their provider makes them feel during pregnancy.

Do you feel:

Heard?
Respected?
Informed?
Safe asking questions?
Comfortable saying no?
Comfortable changing your mind?

Those answers matter deeply.

There Is No “Perfect” Birth

One of the most harmful ideas in birth culture is the belief that there is only one correct way to give birth.

When birth is framed too rigidly, people often leave feeling like failures if their plans change.

We hear this constantly:

“I failed because I got an epidural.”
“I failed because I got induced.”
“I failed because I needed a C-section.”
“I failed because I changed my mind.”

But birth is not a test.

You do not earn worthiness through suffering.
You do not become more powerful by avoiding interventions.
You do not fail because your birth unfolded differently than expected.

Birth is deeply individual.

And sometimes the most empowering choice is:

Getting the epidural
Accepting induction
Choosing a C-section
Declining an intervention
Changing your plan halfway through labor

Empowerment comes from informed choice—not from meeting someone else’s definition of the “ideal” birth.

Why Informed Consent Matters So Much

As our views evolved, one concept became increasingly central to our philosophy: informed consent.

True informed consent means:

Understanding benefits
Understanding risks
Understanding alternatives
Having the ability to say yes or no freely
Being allowed to change your mind

This applies to all birth decisions:

Epidurals
Pitocin
Cervical exams
Antibiotics
Induction
Cesarean birth
Monitoring
Position changes

Providers should educate without coercion. Support people should support without fearmongering. And clients deserve space to make decisions aligned with their own values and comfort levels.

Birth Workers Should Continue Growing

One of the most important things we’ve learned is that growth is essential in birth work.

We are not the same providers we were 10 years ago.

And honestly?
That’s a good thing.

Experience, reflection, continuing education, and client feedback have all shaped the way we support families today.

We’ve learned:

To listen more
To judge less
To collaborate better
To communicate differently
To hold space for many types of birth experiences

We’ll likely continue evolving over the next decade too.

Birth work should never become rigid. It should remain curious, compassionate, and adaptable.

Our Current Philosophy on Birth

Today, our philosophy is simple:

There is room for it all.

There is room for:

Home birth
Hospital birth
Birth centers
Epidurals
Unmedicated labor
Inductions
C-sections
Midwives
OBs
Doulas
Physiologic birth
Medical intervention

What matters most is that people:

Feel informed
Feel respected
Feel supported
Feel empowered in their decision-making

We don’t want families making decisions out of fear. We want them making decisions from understanding, confidence, and trust.

Because at the end of the day, there is no single “right” birth.

There is only the birth experience that feels right for you.